What’s wrong with the food forest concept?

Organic gardener Julian Blackhirst questions the ‘bare foot, lazy gardener’ idea

Permaculture’s food forest idea
The concept of a food forest has become a popular, almost mythical, approach to growing food. Rooted in permaculture, the idea is to emulate the natural structure of a forest. Taller fruit, nut or timber species provide the canopy layer of the ‘forest’.
In the understory section, smaller fruiting plants like berries, currants and dwarf fruit trees are grown. Vegetables and herbs grow on ground level. Priority is given to perennial crops which remain in place year after year.

Images spring to mind of the lazy gardener (possibly bare foot) wandering whimsically through the forest garden, foraging the bounty that nature has provided without having to lift a spade or replant crops with each season.
As time went on however the limitations of the “forest garden” became all too apparent. Taller plants like the hazelnuts and larger fruit came to dominate.
Once the taller plants became established the competition for light and root space made growing useful food crops underneath them near impossible. None of our vegetable or smaller fruit species are happy growing in the shade of established trees or competing with their root zone.
When you look at the origins of most of our food crops,
it is hard to find any which are at home growing as an understory plant in a forest environment.
Most of our common vegetables have been developed by gardeners over millennia to enjoy rich, deep, garden soil in full sun. The plants which we chose to develop as our staple food crops were usually taken from river delta areas or fertile, mixed pastures; again with rich, deep soil and plenty of sunlight.

Limited range of perennial crops
The focus on perennial crops was another problem. In our temperate climate there is a very limited range of perennial food crops.
After establishing a good-sized patch of rhubarb and asparagus, gardeners find themselves planting increasingly obscure and unpalatable species. Although technically edible, they are no match for the flavour and sophistication of our beautiful heirloom vegetables grown in our mini-plot.
The question of the gardener’s role in nature also comes into play. In a food forest planted with perennial crops, human involvement in the garden is limited at every point other than design. The gardener is not an integral part
of the garden any more; it runs and perpetuates without human involvement and the gardener’s relationship to the garden he or she has designed is more that of a ‘hunter gatherer’ in the wilderness.
For passionate gardeners and beginners alike, the idea of minimising the gardener’s role in the garden is undesirable.
I want to be gardening, growing, cultivating and getting my hands dirty. Gardens, like the vegetables and fruit we grow in them, are human creations.
The role of the gardener as creator, cultivator and curator of their creations shows how humans can exist with and contribute to nature in a positive and harmonious way.
Our food forest is now making way for additions to our fruit orchard, vegetable gardens and herbs. The diversity and soil health which comes from planting under the orchard has not been lost. Comfrey, Russian garlic and a wide selection of herbs provide great companions to
our fruit trees; attract beneficial insects, help control pests and continuously improve the soil.
Our adjacent vegetable gardens will still benefit from being in a diverse garden full of flowers, herbs, native birds and insects, but will be dedicated, manicured, vegetable plots with gardeners nurturing them every day.

Editor’s note: We would love to hear your views about this idea and your experiences with other permaculture garden concepts. Please email editor@diggers.com.au


Autumn Vegie Gardening

Bernadette Brady chooses the vegetables to plant when temperatures are falling

Be Your Own Kitchen Gardener

Robyn Fox explains the secrets behind growing heirlooms for Heronswood's restaurant

Can we trust others to grow our food?

Clive Blazey talks about the destruction of our food quality

Community Food Gardening

Bernadette Brady explains how community food gardening overcomes social alienation

Creating an Edible Landscape

Bill Bampton talks about the challenges of combining beauty and functionality in the garden

Extend your life by eating lots of fibre

Clive Blazey explains why processed and fast foods are making us sick

Grow Your Own Garlic

Garlic expert Penny Woodward explains why it can be so tricky to grow

Grow Your Own Greens

Bernadette Brady shows us the fibre foods to plant in autumn and grow through winter

Grow Your Own Herbs

Bill Bampton's top ten points for herb growing

Growing Your Own in the Edible City

Indira Naido relates her adventures in gardening on her inner city balcony

Heirloom Fruit

Marcus Ryan explains why fruit doesn't taste as good as it used to

Heirloom Silverbeet and Beetroot

Clive Blazey explains how almost all the vegetables we eat today were available before 1900!


Jac Semmler tells you why spring is the time to get excited about growing heirloom tomatoes

Making a beautiful garden edible

Bill Bampton explains how to create a food border by combining the ornamental potential of edibles with the edible potential of ornamentals

Plant Based Fibre

Arabella Forge explains why you should eat more fruit and vegetables

Pumpkins Better Than Butternut

Evette Jungwirth ponders on producing the perfect pumpkin

Q&A - Cane Fruit

Cane fruit guru Phil Rowe answers your questions about berries

Q&A - Citrus

Citrus expert Ian Tolley answers your questions about citrus trees and fruit

Q&A - Fruit Trees

Julian Blackhirst answers your questions about summer pruning and general care of fruit trees

Q&A - Tomato Growing

Our experts Julie, Tim and Evette answer your questions about growing tomatoes

Start Your First Food Garden

Bernadette Brady encourages you to start your own vegie garden

The urban herbalist

Bill Bampton's top ten herbs to grow in containers

Unusual edibles

Arno King introduces southern gardeners to some northern vegetable staples that succeed down south
Back To Top
Member Exclusives
Grow your own summer vegie garden with this instant collection of our top tasting heirloom vegetables! The pack comes with our three best tasting tomatoes ('Tommy Toe', 'Pink Bumblebee' and 'Crazy Barry'), plus 3 'California Wonder' capsicums, 3 'Listada di Gandia' Italian Eggplants, and 5 Basil speedings plus Heirloom Lettuce Mix and Lebanese C...
Member $39.95
Checking stock, please wait..
The essential starter pack to begin your cottage flower border. Includes three plants each of Catmint `Walker's Low' and Evening Primrose `Pink' - a surefire combination that we use at Heronswood to create a long- flowering display of pastel pinks and blues.
Member $34.50
Non-Member $47.70
Checking stock, please wait..
Membership: MNE2VS
Join The Diggers Club for 2 years for $79, just $39.50 per year and you'll receive a FREE Vegetable Seed Collection which includes 1 packet each of Spring Onion Red, Tomato Tigerella, Beetroot Chioggia and Silverbeet 5 Colour mix. The normal price for this collection is $23.75. You'll also receive our 'Welcome to the Club'gift of 2 more free pac...
Member $79.00
Non-Member $79.00
Checking stock, please wait..